40 Years Later, ‘Chicago 7’ Trial Still an Iconic Event ABA Journal
Posted Oct 21, 2009 By Martha Neil
A perfect storm of political unrest, generational conflict and a biased judge set the stage for a 1969 trial that is still memorable 40 years later for its drama and iconic import, participants in an American Bar Association panel told a standing-room-only audience Tuesday.
Although the months-long Chicago Seven conspiracy trial ignited international debate—one searing image was of a bound and gagged Bobby Seale, originally the eighth defendant in U.S. v. Dellinger, et al.—panelists offered a behind-the-scenes glimpse of little-known aspects of the high-profile trial. Brought against activists who participated in anti-Vietnam War protests at the Democratic National Convention in 1968, the federal case offered an opportunity for defendants including Tom Hayden, Abbie Hoffman and Jerry Rubin to create a media circus, and they took full advantage of it.
The effort was aided by a trial judge who offered a substantial target for criticism at the best of times and for this case was "the worst possible judge," recounted partner Thomas Sullivan of Jenner & Block, who was then a young lawyer in Chicago. Baited viciously by defendants and counsel, U.S. District Judge Julius Hoffman eventually handed down hefty contempt terms that were reversed on appeal.
From the outset, however, Hoffman clearly favored the prosecution, according to Sullivan and other panelists.
After Seale's intended lawyer was stricken with a gall-bladder attack three days before the trial was to begin, Hoffman scoured the pleadings to identify other attorneys who had entered an appearance in the case on Seale's behalf for peripheral purposes. Finding four, the judge sent a court marshal out to locate the lawyers and bring them in to defend Seale, briefly jailing two attorneys who didn't come in voluntarily, Sullivan said.
When the four lawyers, represented by Sullivan, told Hoffman they weren't adequately prepared to try the case, he attempted to jail all four over the weekend until another judge intervened.
As the case progressed, a parade of celebrity witnesses took the stand, noted journalist Rich Samuels, who presented a program on the trial for local news affairs program Chicago Tonight. They included folk singer Judy Collins and Timothy Leary, a well-known fan of the drug LSD who had earlier taught psychology at Harvard University,
After months of trial that stretched into 1970, the jury was deadlocked. But a verdict was finally reached after a court official told holdouts that the judge could keep them in the courthouse until they rendered a decision. "That terrified them," said John Schultz, who covered the entire Chicago Seven trial as a reporter for the Evergreen Review and has written a book about the case.
Jurors were originally unwilling to talk about the verdict, but Schultz persevered, and his coverage helped point the way toward a successful appeal.
Although widely viewed as an incendiary factor in an out-of-control trial, Hoffman himself initially saw the Chicago Seven case as a high point in his career and was proud of having played an important role in it, said Jeffrey Cole, a federal magistrate and adjunct law professor who as a young attorney was involved in the appeal. "He thought this was a turning point in the history of the whole country."
Repeatedly invited by Hoffman to discuss the case, post-trial, in the wealthy jurist's exquisitely furnished chambers, Cole noted that the judge had framed the few newspaper articles that took a favorable view of the trial. After being criticized by the Chicago-based 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for his handling of the case, however, Hoffman eventually died "a very disappointed and horribly unhappy man," Cole said.